Every time I sit down to write this entry, something changes the underlying theme. Well, it was supposed to be done Christmas Eve, and here it is the 27th. Despite the Heisenberg Effect surrounding this topic, it's time to put words to page.
I often tell people about Georg Hegel's treatise on interpersonal relations, called "Lordship and Bondage," from his book
Phenomenology of the Spirit. I know, title sounds racy, but trust me, no whips and chains--maybe we'll talk about Michel Foucault another time, though. "Lordship and Bondage" is one of the favorite things I took away from my failed attempt to double major in Philosophy. (I know...that's even more useless a major than English (Writing), but let's just roll with it. As an aside, I was one credit short: Symbolic Logic never struck me as logical, nor did I really ever think it was symbolic of much....) Hegel was a phenomenologist, someone who believed that the only way to confirm the world around us is via sense data--what we can see, hear, smell, touch, taste--and that everything outside of the self is an object unless confirmed as a subject by the self.
Hegel postulates that when two people interact initially, they are trying to convince the other of their own perception of themselves, to externally validate. And that, sooner or later, one person is more successful than the other enough that the other is turned into a mirror, or slave, and the "more successful" person becomes the "master" of the relationship.
But see, it doesn't work out so nice and neatly, Hegel explains. Because the master sooner or later realizes that an object like the slave cannot confer subjecthood and the confirmation of the master's self-perception as valid. Mirrors don't validate; they just reflect. And, at the same time, the slave usually figures out they're supplying the master with something the master values, so they start rationing those morsels of external validation out. So, at some point, the master must confirm the slave as a subject, lest the master become the slave and the slave the master, doling out that confirmation of self-perceived self like crack to the addicted master.
Ernest Hemingway believed that all relationships were transactional. He'd go into a wine peddler's shop and introduce himself, Ernest Hemingway, the novelist, perhaps you'd heard of him, and suggest that he was writing a novel about the area, and everyone told him this was
the place to buy wine in the area, and he was wondering if the guy would mind being placed in the novel. Oh, he'll fuzz the details just enough for sake of anonymity, but fans will know how to get there still. The merchant would usually sell that old drunk Papa vino at a tremendous discount right then and there.
A play I saw, called
Art, is all about these old school chums who get together each Christmas. They've been friends for years, but this Christmas, a painting exposes them to the scary question they've been avoiding all those years:
If we share nothing in common anymore, then why are we still even friends?
So, yeah, now that we're all depressed thinking that everyone precious in our lives is merely there because they're out to get something and I've shown off my college edu-ma-cation, let's dispense with the liberal arts hoighty-toighty, leather elbow patch crap and start talking about my friends and family like they're something aside from lab rats.
The oft-repeated line I use goes something like this: I think my friends should be entitled to hazard pay, and every once in a while, possibly fire zone pay as well. The suggestion being that it's tough and sometimes dangerous to be my friend. And while nobody's shooting at me (usually), it sometimes can be. But oftentimes, even the best of us are a little lazy in our relationships with other people. Even the best of us can be a little selfish little tyrants. We're like the kid who comes to the playground with the ball: if you want to play ball, we think, you gotta play by my rules. Nobody goes through life wanting to be the co-star in someone else's movie life. We don't want to be the sidekick. We want to be the guy who gets the girl. The girl who becomes the celebrity. The person who
makes a difference in someone's life. We want to have meaning. We want validation that
yes, I am a good and worthwhile person. I do deserve these wonderful things that have happened to me, these wonderful people in my life. Because, if you look yourself in the mirror long enough, somewhere deep down, we all feel a little like we've gotten by sometimes, that we've floated a check that should have bounced, metaphorically speaking, and that sooner or later, the jig will be up, the masquerade will be revealed, and everyone will know we didn't deserve these wonderful things, these wonderful people.
When they banned smoking (I'm in the process of quitting, so it's on my mind) in British pubs, the texting traffic in the UK skyrocketed. The smokers, feeling left out of the conversations they left inside to puff their cancer sticks, were trying to connect, to touch another person. They were feeling guilty about their smoking, and trying to make up for it.
Guilt is a big motivator in our lives. Confidence in ourselves is sometimes as hard to find as faith in a divine order to the universe. When the two come together at cross purposes...oh, brother, have we got issues....
This is me coming around to a point:
For a long time, in my private moments, I have felt truly unworthy of the wonderful people in my life. It's made me feel guilty sometimes, like a liar, a sham, a fake. Conversely, it's led to trouble at times.
For instance: a lot of my friends over the years have found
themselves in a jam, and I've swooped in to the rescue, sometimes from
halfway across the country, sometimes at seemingly great sacrifice on my
part. They always think I'm doing it because I care about them that
much. And, yes, I do. But somewhere deep down in my subconscious (and in
yours, too, maybe, if you root around in there long enough) there might
have sometimes been a guilt-ridden need to do it, so that when the
truth that I'm undeserving of their loyalty and affection comes out,
they'll take pity on me and remain my friend.
Someone with a problem usually denies the problem, then avoids it when there's no more denying it. Then things can get combative. It's like the stages of grief almost. And at the end of the steps of grieving, there is acceptance.
I'm not saying I'm there, but I'm a helluva lot closer than I was last year.
These crises of confidence are simple human failings. We all have them. Yeah, me being me, I tend to over-analyzing them to the point that they're so clinically vivisected that they don't even resemble emotions anymore, but that doesn't make me any different than the rest of us, really. Alright, it makes me a little OCD, despite the usually cluttered chaos I prefer to work and live in, but otherwise, I think I'm not that different than anyone else.
We want that person to validate us. As a good worker. As a good son or daughter. As a good parent. As a good student. As a good mentor. As a good leader or follower. As a good friend. As a good lover. Sometimes, when we're missing one of these, the very suggestion of criticism makes us rabid. Someone who has been single a long time suddenly grousing about a couple in love being annoying isn't always complaining about the public displays of affection; they're often enough complaining that they're not receiving any public displays of affection themselves. We covet when we lack. That's as human as the first neanderthal moving into a cave and the second neanderthal wanting to move into one to keep out of the rain, too.
But let's bring Hemingway back into the equation.
All relationships are transactional, Papa says. So, in theory, there's a social contract between me and each of my friends. Did we actually have a written and signed document, like my friends Spider and Willow jokingly made when they dated, enumerating exceptions and clauses, and designating a third party (you guessed it: yours, truly) to arbitrate all disputes or possible breaches of contract? Of course not. We've got more of an oral agreement to broad terms, like Hemingway's idea that stories are like icebergs. Sure, we don't know the exact shape, but we have a general notion of shape. (
Note: If anyone does have any line item stipulations for our friendships going forward, I'd be amused and eager for you to express them.)
Sometimes, we fail to hold up our end of the bargain. We're human; shit happens. We don't compliment you on an achievement. Our support is absent at a critical crossroads in your life. We leave the toilet seat up. We don't do this stuff on purpose; sometimes our own lives got in the way, or we had other people--other contractual obligations, if you will--that took precedence. Like I said, shit happens.
What's dangerous is when shit willfully and wantonly happens. When someone takes that contract and uses it as a manipulative tool. When someone plays on our emotional investment in a relationship to get what they want out of you. When someone reduces you back to Hegel's slave, and plays at being a master.
We've all had it done. We've maybe all done it a time or two, if we were going to be honest with ourselves. Not our finest hour. Probably another cocktail of guilt on the bar tab there, Ernest.
The thing is, friends forgive. It's part of who they are. I'm not saying rush out and confess your transgressions. Jimmy doesn't need to know that you met and had a fling with Sally after twenty years of silence and four years of marriage on the subject, but he might definitely need to know if that math comes out a little differently. But we aren't perfect, and we really shouldn't expect our friends to be perfect, either.
Lemme drag one more metaphor into the mix here to make my point, and then we can move on: I always fall for women with flaws. The girl I couldn't ever kiss quite right. The girl who when she gets up in the morning has no sense of balance for the first five or ten minutes. Yeah, Helen Hunt is an off-beat beauty, but there's a girl out there right now that when the light's right and she looks at me a certain way, I always think she looks like Helen Hunt, and it always makes me feel like she's Helen of Troy. Not because I've got a thing for Helen Hunt, but because it's a psychological tick, a neurological cross-fire in my brain that always happens, that might annoy most people, but I for some reason can't get enough of. I mean, go back to that mirror, give yourself a long look, and admit it: your present or past lover had some little flaw that you just couldn't get enough of, and while they might have hated it, it was/is part of what made you fall for them as hard as you did.
It's similar, but not the same, with friendships. I have friends I made back in the college days that were so close that I turned to them when my father died, and now, we've got nothing in common. But they're still important to me, despite the fact we sometimes each probably wonder why the hell we're still friends, like those guys in
Art.
And then the right hits, and we remember.
I have been fortunate in my life. That old Chinese curse,
May you live in interesting times, has been a beneficial one so far, and a little mantra I jokingly reflect on when I'm looking at the shape of my life thus far. There's a poem I wrote back in college, "Rachel," in which I refer to life as a "house half-built." (Rachel, who is sadly not with us anymore, probably never read that poem, maybe never even knew she was the type of woman that could inspire a poem, and I really wish I could have shared that with her. She might still be with us if I had.) It was literally a metaphor I wrote without really truly appreciating its meaning or import, but of course, my mentor, R, seized upon and gushed over. It's become the way I look at my life ever since he explained to me what my random literary misfire meant to him.
I find it appropriate that, now, on the cusp of moving into this big, presently empty condo, and having to re-situate all the kipple (Thank you, Philip K. Dick, for that lovely bit of poetic license) that constitutes my household goods, that I'm talking about the half-built house of life right now. Because those rooms of the house, they're not filled with furniture. They're filled with memories, with these "cold social contracts" I referred to before, re-fashioned in warm, pleasant ties that bind me to those people.
I always joke that girls at a certain age plan their weddings, and that boys around the same age instead plan funerals, with the unspoken nod to Tom and Huck popping up at their own supposed funerals. And it's true, as far as it goes. But there was a moment when someone got me thinking about a wedding, too, and I had a realization. And that realization led to me actually cobbling together the first part of a wedding toast to the as-yet-unidentified-but-hopefully-soon-but-not-too-soon-to-grace-us-with-her-identity Mrs. Josh, or maybe even part of our vows if she's into cooking up our own. I've never shared it with anyone, and I won't say who inspired it, as she'd most likely die of terminal embarrassment, or at the least kick me firmly in the teeth for never telling her she inspired such a thought. Well, it's appropriate to the occasion, so I'm going to share it.
In our infancy, we are swaddled. We're bound up tightly in blankets, and we find comfort in that. As we grow up, we do everything we can to be free of any such bondage, to be unbound in the truest, purest sense. It's when we find someone who makes us want to be bound, to be tied to them, to be re-swaddled and cast aside that need for freedom, that we truly know what love and life are all about.
Now, that's love. But these ties between us and our friends? They're probably lesser expressions of something vaguely similar. These people I've surrounded myself with? You all had a purpose for being included at some point. Don't worry if you don't know what it was, we're past that. And I likely don't remember either. We don't need to have purposes to our friends. We just need to be us, warts and all.
A friend will give you an alibi, the old joke goes. A best friend will help you hide the body.
I'm lucky to have the folks I do in my life. And this whole philosophical and psychological run-around was me making sure that I took the time to say it. Oh, I probably made a hash of it, and at some point or another bored you to tears before we got here, but, would I be me if I didn't?
Now, one more thing I need to say, then I'm hitting publish and considering hitting pubs.
Family. I lost my father at 20, and while there's a lot to say about him, I'm setting Dad aside for another time (Believe me, he'll get more than his due down the road). I am lucky enough to have my mother and three brothers, one of whom has been lucky enough to bring a daughter into the world to add to the family. We aren't the best family. We aren't the typical family. We are likely dysfunctional and a little scary at times. But I love them. I cherish them. We've had more trauma and drama than a lot of families, but we've weathered most if not all of that hardship together. And while every once in a while I say "your mother" or "your brother" when I'm upset, I wouldn't trade them for anyone else's family.
A few years after my father died, my youngest brother and I were playing catch. He was ten. He was tossing the ball well enough that I didn't have to move the glove. I put a little more power on my tosses, and he naturally did the same out of reflex. I told him we were going to try something different, and got down into a catcher's stance.
Damned if he wasn't the starting pitcher the next season for his little league team. I got a lot of secondhand parental experience, my dad passing as early as he did, but that's the one memory of paternal pride that if I died tomorrow I'd take to my grave.
Every one of my brothers has a moment they're a part of that I treasure. Alright, Mom, too, but don't push. They're not the same. Hell, they're not even close. But they're moments that when I think of them, I feel the warmth of family, even over here on a tropical island in the afternoon while they're on the other side of the planet sound asleep (except for the pitcher; I think he's got insomnia again).
So, this holiday, I wanted to thank them for being my family, even if they didn't have a choice in the matter.
We now return you to our regular programming already in progress. I'm not sure if all this rambling meant anything to you, but I hope it did. It's one of my promises to myself to recognize my friends and family's value to me a little more often, and to be more worthy of them going forward from today.